Thursday, May 17, 2007

Water: bottling your own

Last Saturday there was an interesting article in Canada's National Newspaper, The Globe and Mail, on drinking water. Well, more specifically on bottled water. Deep in the recesses of my brain I knew I had read somewhere that Pepsi-Cola and Coca-Cola both bottle municipal tap water and re-sell it, one as Aquafina and the other as Dasani. They get their municipal tap water from Mississauga and Brampton.

I am grateful to the author of this article, for bringing the wet reality more strongly into my consciousness. I don't use bottled water very often because we have a filter at the source of the municipal water entrance to our home. I do enjoy the reduced chlorine taste this filtration process provides. When I am traveling, or I forget to put water in my car cup before I leave the house, I buy bottled water. Often it is Dasani or Aqaufina. Really, I'd be getting the same product if I entered a Tim Horton's or Starbucks and asked for a cup filled with tap water. According to the article, if I just stir the water and let it sit for a bit the chlorine taste will be gone.

As a coach, drinking plenty of water is something I’ve recommend more times than I could ever count. I suggest water when people tell me they hit a low point during the afternoon, or when they experience muscle cramps during a training walk or race. The first line of defense should be to drink some water. Headaches, muscle fatigue, a dry cough and many other symptoms of dehydration are experienced every day by people who have come to accept these feelings of low energy as normal. A single glass of water may be all that is needed to feel good.

Still, whether we need bottled water to feel good is controversial. Several of the plastics from which these bottles, including the polyethylene terephthalate (#1 PET) of single-use popularity, are manufactured leach chemicals into their contents. Essentially, if your water tastes like plastic, you are drinking the chemicals that have gone into making that plastic.

In recent years, sports enthusiasts have taken to using the harder polycarbonate bottle, the most popular brand being Nalgene. (Several of us got really nice versions of this in our race kits for the Ottawa Full Marathon, two years ago!) Now, there is some evidence that the hard #7 polycarbonate plastic in these bottles may leach an artificial estrogen into its contents.

What’s an ethical, environmentally-minded, health-conscious power walking addict to do? Well, general consensus seems to suggest that we do not use single-use bottles again for re-fills. Also, common environmental sense suggests that we try to reduce the number of plastic bottles we buy.

Experts are now recommending the use of polypropylene (#5 PP), which is not known to leach harmful substances, as well as high density polyethylene#2 HDPE and low density polyethylene#4 LDPE for refillable water bottles.

Some people are not waiting for the next bad-news scenario on these plastics and are switching to stainless or glass containers. Glass might be a bit tricky for power walkers and stainless steel can get heavy, so ultimately the decision is yours.

If you are a power walker trying to stay on top of your hydration needs, your long-term health may be worth some thoughtful consideration as to how you are storing your water.

Finally, don’t forget…you can also worry your way sick! Above all: get outside, get power walking!

Labels:

3 Comments:

At May 18, 2007 2:10 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

I cannot let this unadulterated nonsense pass without comment. I have been in the water purification business for over 20 years and if you took the trouble to go to the Aquafina site you would see that it is indeed tap water but it has been highly purified using a reverse osmosis treatment system.
Dasani does not give as much information so no comment.
I am NOT a supporter of the major bottling companies as their product is vastly overpriced but there is no reason for you not to install your own reverse osmosis system at home and get a 99% pure product.
Not smart to klnock stuff if you don't have the facts.

Roger Price
Brisbane Australia
rlprice@bigpond.com

 
At May 18, 2007 7:23 AM , Blogger Wow Power Walking Founder said...

Roger,

Thanks for your input to our forum. It is our hope that anything posted here inspires discussion. The article to which I was referring did mention that both Dasani and Aquafina further purify the municipal water.

By the way, the filtration system at my home is a reverse osmosis unit and I plan to
keep it.

Lee

 
At May 21, 2007 8:27 AM , Blogger Penny said...

Another thought and a good way to reduce overeating: Sometimes when you feel hungry, you're actually thirsty.
I have trouble getting my kids to use refillable bottles of any kind.They like the convenience and light weight of 500 ml bottles. But I'll keep trying - thanks for the encouragement!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home